Verified Document

Native Americans, New Voices: American Reaction Paper

He describes that Native American population as having incredible adaptability and perseverance (Edmunds, p. 728). I fear that this conclusion is an attempt at trying to avoid sounding disparaging about a minority group that ignores some of the harsher realties of modern life for the vast majority of Native Americans in the modern United States. Yes, his conclusion that the numbers of Native Americans in the United States have increased dramatically from their all-time low is true. However, judging the robustness of a civilization based only on its population numbers seems to be a very reductionist approach. Moreover, it lumps Native American populations together in a way that seems inaccurate. Modern Native American populations are "in all stages of development, from the most primitive to the most sophisticated. In the United States, they still speak more than 100 different languages" (American Indian Council). Moreover, the reality is that many of these different populations are in such distressed conditions that it would be irresponsible to suggest that they are somehow prospering in any way. While some Native Americans are doing well, "many thousands live at near-starvation levels. Some are educated and completely assimilated in white society; many live in nearly complete isolation from non-Indian-Americans. Relocation programs have taken hundreds of Indians to work in cities; thousands of others cling to the security of their reservations, hoping to gain education and assistance necessary to develop the resources of their lands and become self-sustaining"...

Moreover, since Native Americans have been self-determining populations since 1975, these results simply do not support the idea of a resilient community as described by Edmunds (Oberg, p.324). My concern with this optimistic description of Native American populations is that it is a way to minimize damage to Native American populations and may actually work against them ever getting the necessary resilience to ever thrive again.
In summary, there are points in Edmunds article that are undoubtedly true. His descriptions of the historical treatment of Native Americans by predominantly non-Native scholars are very accurate, and there does not seem to be any obvious errors in his conclusions about what this scholarly treatment of Native Americans implied about the surrounding social conditions of those time periods. However, I must fundamentally disagree with his conclusion about the resilience of Native Americans, insofar as that refers to a broader social group and culture. Some cultures have shown almost no resilience and the overall condition of Native Americans in modern America is still distressed.

Works Cited

American Indians Cultural Network. "American Indians Today." American Indians Cultural

Network. N.p. 2000. Web. 25 Nov. 2012.

Edmunds, R. David. "Native Americans, New Voices: American Indian History, 1895-1995."

American Historical Review (June 1995): 717-740.

Oberg, Michael Leroy. Native America: A History. Malden, MA: John Wiley and Sons, 2010.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

American Indians Cultural Network. "American Indians Today." American Indians Cultural

Network. N.p. 2000. Web. 25 Nov. 2012.

Edmunds, R. David. "Native Americans, New Voices: American Indian History, 1895-1995."

American Historical Review (June 1995): 717-740.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Native Americans Transition From Freedom to Isolation
Words: 2805 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Native Americans Transition From Freedom to Isolation America's history since 1865 to date is a remarkable record of various accounts of despair, hope, triumph, and tragedy. The country's history consists of some compelling transformations with one of these significant accounts being the battle between Americans and Americans in the final period of the Civil War. In its initial years, the United States was politically isolated from the rest of the world

Native Americans Dakota and Lakota People the
Words: 2063 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Native Americans Dakota and Lakota people The word 'Dakota' is derived from the seven council fires (Oceti Sakowin) - or in other words, the main political units for the people of Dakota. The word means "ally" also referred to as "Sioux" at times. Historically, the Sisseton, Wahpekute, Wahpeton, and Mdewakanton constituted of western Yankton and Yanktonai who were together referred to as Nakota and the Teton and Eastern Dakota. The Santee Dakota

Native Americans Portrayed Works Ben Franklin John
Words: 596 Length: 2 Document Type: Thesis

Native Americans portrayed works Ben Franklin John Smith? Do authors treat a favorable negative light? Be introduction a distinct thesis statement, a body specific supporting elements, a conclusion essay. Many influential people in the history of the U.S. have played an active role in either improving society's relationship with Native Americans or in damaging it by portraying them as individuals who were savages. Benjamin Franklin was among the people who

Professional Communication: Cultural Sensitivity Among Native Americans...
Words: 1623 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Professional Communication: Cultural Sensitivity Among Native Americans In nursing school, we are normally taught that we should respect the dignity and rights of all clients. As the "world becomes reduced" and societies and individuals become more mobile, we are progressively able to network with people that are from other cultures. Cultural respect and competence for others becomes particularly significant for us as nurses and patient supporters. Applying the principles and theories

Southwest Native Americans Long Before
Words: 1305 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Their neutrality across time has granted them with a long-lasting and strong community. What is intriguing about the Zuni people is that their language does not resemble any other language of the neighboring Pueblos. Moreover, they are the only people in the world to speak the Zuni language. (Minnesota State University Mankato) The Pueblo society has usually been ruled in a theocratic manner, with the head of the tribe also being

Removal of the Native Americans
Words: 3097 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

He was viewing them as little children who required guidance. He tended to believe that the policy of removal had great benefits to the Indians. Majority of the white Americans were thinking that United States was not capable of extending past Mississippi. The removal was capable of saving the Indian nationals from the white's depredations (Foreman 1932). The removal could make them to govern themselves peacefully It was assumed that the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now